Sfdebris.net

Obviously not a VS thread, and not even a hypothetical what-if given how old Stewart is and that Rickman is dead, making any chance at such a scenario literally impossible. This is just to set up an idea - that an incarnation of the Doctor is Patrick Stewart, another incarnation of the Master Alan Rickman - and to discuss how and where they'd play off one another, given their performances on screen.

What do you guys think?

I must again re-emphasize, this is not a debate on who'd beat who. It's just a discussion on the kind of flavor and nuances they'd bring to their roles if, say, we were transported to the alternate universe where Patrick Stewart signed onto Doctor Who instead of being Captain Picard and grew into his character there instead of on TNG and Alan Rickman became the Master instead of starring in Die Hard, so their careers went to the top in other ways. The dates are such that it could have happened with enough tweaking in another reality.

IMO, one of Dr. Who's traits is Who's mixture of eccentricity + gravitas. IMO, Patrick Stewart inherently has too much gravitas and not enough wackiness to be a doctor.

Even when Stewart is playing a whimsical/eccentric character---- https://www.youtube.com/results?search_ ... tor+is+out

Well, Hartnell was something of a dignified man, no reason he couldn't be again, though I get it - that was decades ago, even using the hypothetical idea that this came about in an alternate late 1980s.