Predicting future scores!

[Yukaphile]

Yeah, figured this might be an interesting thread.

Um... I'll go first. I'm gonna say Chuck will rate "Pathfinder" a 7, given that it's a good episode, and Neelix doesn't appear, so... wait, scratch that, make it an 8.

Anyone else got an opinion?

[Yukaphile]

Just remembered, Neelix DOES appear. His part was so small, though, he might as well have not. Oops.

So, a 7 it is.

[BridgeConsoleMasher]

I only guess when I watch the review. Listening to his points and having a good sense of what generally detracts or appreciates, I guess at the tail end and judge both what he's bringing up and how I feel about the episode. When I'm significantly off, it's usually because I like the episode for some aspect and don't catch his tone on matters.

Also interesting, the score was coming up for Retrospect and I didn't really have a guess. Turned out to be a 5, go figure.

[Yukaphile]

Well, I think given that "Pathfinder" was a good Reg episode, what he said about Barclay in the finale, and that it rarely showed Neelix, and took place off Voyager and on Earth, a 7 or 8 seems reasonable.

I think "Prey" will get a 6 or a 7.

[Sir Will]

Hmm... maybe 6-7 for Business as Usual? He has a soft spot for Quark and he gets to show his heart in this episode.

Virtuoso a 5? I don't know.

Hard to say cause I haven't seen these episodes on years, just looking them up on Memory Alpha to refresh my memory.

[Yukaphile]

I think "Hunters" will likewise fall in the 6 or 7 ranges.

[sayla0079]

Well considering he Gave Field of Fire a 5 and thats usually considered one of the better Ezri centric episodes ten to one he gives prodigal daughter a 4 at most and probably afterimage a 4

[Sir Will]

Well considering he Gave Field of Fire a 5 and thats usually considered one of the better Ezri centric episodes ten to one he gives prodigal daughter a 4 at most and probably afterimage a 4

Prodigal daughter doesn't seem like a very popular episode. I thought it was fine but, yeah, I think 4 is the highest it would go.

[sayla0079]

Well considering he Gave Field of Fire a 5 and thats usually considered one of the better Ezri centric episodes ten to one he gives prodigal daughter a 4 at most and probably afterimage a 4

Prodigal daughter doesn't seem like a very popular episode. I thought it was fine but, yeah, I think 4 is the highest it would go.

Oh I like the episode don't get me wrong but well it could have been done better. Either way I think its going to score lower then Afterimage

[Yukaphile]

I think "Inside Man" will get a 5. As much as he loves Reg Barclay, I do think he'll say even his generosity has limits, and it's ultimately an episode of a hologram tricking the dumb, gullible Voyager crew.