Favorite Trek movie review?

[Yukaphile]

Mine is "The Wrath of Khan."

[bronnt]

[Zoinksberg]

At what point is this considered spam and grounds for banning? Is that the goal here? Maybe Yuka needs a break but needs to be banned so he sticks with it?

[Yukaphile]

And there you go again, questioning my motives, even though, like with all those other threads, this was merely to generate discussion, and considering how negative those were, I figured I'd try something positive, didn't even go on that big a tangent at the beginning, stayed on topic - and people still complained! What will satisfy you, huh? A written contract in blood? This is why I have to take long breaks at a time, because it's not all just me - people's perceptions of me are so damaged that when I stay within the rules and don't do anything bad, it's still somehow controversial.

Well, just to let you know, I don't intend to take part in these conversations. So, there you go. I just wanted to generate discussion, and I'm determined to see that through to the end - with or without me.

[Zoinksberg]

Guess my favorite Trek movie review will be for the Tarantino one.

[BridgeConsoleMasher]

I'd probably say IV, though I'm not the most brushed up on his movie reviews. I liked in IV where he covers the scene with Kirk telling Spock about how everybody in the 80's cussed every other sentence. Then the whale gab with the probe was pretty funny too.

[clearspira]

And there you go again, questioning my motives, even though, like with all those other threads, this was merely to generate discussion, and considering how negative those were, I figured I'd try something positive, didn't even go on that big a tangent at the beginning, stayed on topic - and people still complained! What will satisfy you, huh? A written contract in blood? This is why I have to take long breaks at a time, because it's not all just me - people's perceptions of me are so damaged that when I stay within the rules and don't do anything bad, it's still somehow controversial.

Well, just to let you know, I don't intend to take part in these conversations. So, there you go. I just wanted to generate discussion, and I'm determined to see that through to the end - with or without me.

I think its more the ''saying you are going on a break and then coming back seemingly 24 hrs later'' thing that makes people question your motives. And you have done this at least twice now. I don't mean any offence by saying that I genuinely don't, but it does not look good mate. And it wasn't a throwaway comment either, you started a whole thread to declare your absence.

[Sir Will]

While I hated the previous set of topics because of the subject matter and just different ways of asking basically the same thing, I really don't see what's wrong with this set of topics. I think a topic to discuss our favorite reviews is a great thing. Maybe it could have been condensed, but there are pros and cons to breaking it out this way too.